LOGO

Ultimate Manga Guide Interview, and why I'm not...

http://comicsintheclassroom.net/oo2007_aug14_manga_guide_interview.htm Comics in the Classroom has posted an interview with Jason Thompson

 

I find this this passage of note to my own interests-

 

"CitC: I just found out that Korean comics, called manhwa, are becoming more popular in North America . I know absolutely nothing about these, but I would guess that they are printed in a similar format to manga and have similar style art. Is there anything you can tell us about manhwa?

Jason: Most of the manhwa that have been translated into English have been highly influenced by manga, so it's difficult for the casual reader to tell it apart, aside from the fact that it reads left to right (Korean reads left to right, unlike Japanese) and the characters' names are Korean. In content and themes, they're pretty similar to manga. Sadly there hasn't been nearly as much written about the history and background of Korean comics as there has been about manga. Whereas many American manga fans are also interested in Japanese pop culture in general, there isn't much of a subculture of "manhwa" fans who are interested in manhwa and Korea specifically. Instead, it's easier to see Korean comics as part of a general movement by publishers to print "manga-style" comics from all countries, such as Tokyopop and Seven Seas' lines of American and European manga-influenced comics (OEL manga). For the moment, the foreignness and specific qualities of Japanese pop culture is a large part of the appeal of manga; but as American and Korean manga-style comics proliferate, it's possible that this foreign element will melt away in the melting-pot and that manga will truly become a "style" and lose the connotation of any particular country. Personally, whenever I read a Japanese or Korean or American comic, I always keep in mind that it's Japanese or Korean or American... but if you ask the upcoming generation of manga readers who are now in junior high, you might get a different answer.

 

I do admit that as I read more Manwha, my interest in Korean culture is growing- as more Korean animation works it's way over [and establishes itself domestically within Korea], Korean pop music stars such as BoA [of Inu Yasha fame] work their way into pop culture, and Korean comics continue to grow more diverse in what's imported, I think we'll see some shifts in what's thought of Korean works. Likewise, as someone who started reading manga in late junior high slightly over a decade ago, I do lean towards the "different answer" camp when it comes to what manga is.

 

Anyhoo, been watching Twelve Kingdoms, which is fairly awesome stuff, but due to assorted business and still finding the new layout confusing, I'm not posting as much. Hope no one minds. When really interesting news does pop up I'll be sure to let you know about it :)

VIEWS: 664
POPS:
3
REVIEWS:
0
CLIPS:
1
COMMENTS:
5
AVG RATING:
0.0
0.0
ART:
0.0
0.0
STORY:
0.0
0.0
Tags: stuff  Added 2007-08-14 19:10:47
Add Comments

 

Only registered members can post comments


     

Comments

BTW-- Korean anime is a smaller market, mostly being kids shows, the occasional original TV production like Michel or Bastof Syndrome, with the ever so often theatrical film that manages to make it's way over here in some form [such as My Beautiful Girl Mari, which is supposedly really good, and the releasedtheatricallybutnotondvdyet Sky Blue]

2007-08-20 20:01:30


Most Manwha tended to be adapted as dramas [like Full House] or movies. Korean and Taiwanese drama's based on manwha and manga have been big hits throughout asia recently [the current Boys over Flowers/Hana Yori Dango j-drama is actually a remake of the taiwanese adaption, Meteor Garden, based on the manga and mid90's anime]

2007-08-20 19:59:39


Sadly i have seen one Korean anime. It was the movie Armageddon and i didn't like it. A lot of the Japanese anime's are being made in Korea however. I don't think it will be long before we will see Korean made anime based on Manwha's.

2007-08-20 08:10:56


I've enjoyed the manwha I've read, but I haven't seen much of Korean animation as far as I know. On the other hand, Korean live action movies seem to have established a small but constant presence in the US for the past several years. The Host even got a nation wide theatrical release!

2007-08-19 03:08:40


I think that if people would look at the manga section in their bookstore they would see a lot of manwha. The major clou in telling them apart is in the names (I guess that is the easiest way to do it) If you are watching twelve kingdom's that it may be a while before you resurface. I was missing for three days when i watched it.

2007-08-15 08:21:16


User Reviews
There are currently no reviews. To review, click on the review link underneath the content.

Avatar
  • flag
  • POPS: 3
  • PROFILE VIEWS: 664
  • FANS: 70
  • CLANS: 3
  • GENDER: M
  • LOCATION: USA